d->m: Tenor GIFs from GIF button are too verbose #30

Open
opened 2024-01-13 10:47:15 +00:00 by cadence · 1 comment
Owner

On Discord, the GIF button just sends a Tenor link to the chat.

Discord displays this by hiding the link (a recent change) and displaying the GIF in video format due to the server-generated URL preview embed (embed type: video). Link: https://discord.com/channels/1160893336324931584/1160894080998461480/1195587910817300540

Matrix displays this as a link with a URL preview where the URL preview does not animate because Synapse's thumbnailer sucks. Link: https://matrix.to/#/!TqlyQmifxGUggEmdBN:cadence.moe/$hwUkiPp0w2JNXwGdg2Rt07DoZPup8b34s0C6az4izeg?via=cadence.moe&via=matrix.org&via=conduit.rory.gay

(But who knows, maybe Synapse will get a better thumbnailer soon...)

Then, OOYE sees Discord's server-generated video embed, and bridges the video embed to Matrix as well, but this doesn't look very good at all. Link: https://matrix.to/#/!TqlyQmifxGUggEmdBN:cadence.moe/$VAk5MSNGlfopAlCmyYXgfcJtngSadxKoBXkpoFSia7s?via=cadence.moe&via=matrix.org&via=conduit.rory.gay

IDEAL: Matrix users should just see something animated. We should add a special case for Tenor URLs to do the right thing.

On Discord, the GIF button just sends a Tenor link to the chat. Discord displays this by hiding the link (a recent change) and displaying the GIF in video format due to the server-generated URL preview embed (embed type: video). Link: https://discord.com/channels/1160893336324931584/1160894080998461480/1195587910817300540 Matrix displays this as a link with a URL preview where the URL preview does not animate because Synapse's thumbnailer sucks. Link: https://matrix.to/#/!TqlyQmifxGUggEmdBN:cadence.moe/$hwUkiPp0w2JNXwGdg2Rt07DoZPup8b34s0C6az4izeg?via=cadence.moe&via=matrix.org&via=conduit.rory.gay (But who knows, [maybe Synapse will get a better thumbnailer soon...](https://github.com/matrix-org/matrix-spec-proposals/pull/2705)) Then, OOYE sees Discord's server-generated video embed, and bridges the video embed to Matrix as well, but this doesn't look very good at all. Link: https://matrix.to/#/!TqlyQmifxGUggEmdBN:cadence.moe/$VAk5MSNGlfopAlCmyYXgfcJtngSadxKoBXkpoFSia7s?via=cadence.moe&via=matrix.org&via=conduit.rory.gay IDEAL: Matrix users should just see something animated. We should add a special case for Tenor URLs to do the right thing.
Author
Owner

This is mostly fixed with better video embed rendering, but it would still be better if it was less verbose.

This is mostly fixed with better video embed rendering, but it would still be better if it was less verbose.
Sign in to join this conversation.
No Label
No Milestone
No Assignees
1 Participants
Notifications
Due Date
The due date is invalid or out of range. Please use the format 'yyyy-mm-dd'.

No due date set.

Dependencies

No dependencies set.

Reference: cadence/out-of-your-element#30
No description provided.