Only edit events if the text has changed

This commit is contained in:
Cadence Ember 2025-08-29 00:09:18 +12:00
parent 954d41269c
commit c71044fdec
2 changed files with 83 additions and 31 deletions

View file

@ -22,6 +22,10 @@ function eventCanBeEdited(ev) {
return true
}
function eventIsText(ev) {
return ev.old.event_type === "m.room.message" && (ev.old.event_subtype === "m.text" || ev.old.event_subtype === "m.notice")
}
/**
* @param {import("discord-api-types/v10").GatewayMessageCreateDispatchData} message
* @param {import("discord-api-types/v10").APIGuild} guild
@ -121,6 +125,20 @@ async function editToChanges(message, guild, api) {
unchangedEvents.push(...eventsToReplace.filter(ev => !eventCanBeEdited(ev))) // Move them from eventsToRedact to unchangedEvents.
eventsToReplace = eventsToReplace.filter(eventCanBeEdited)
// Now, everything in eventsToReplace has the potential to have changed, but did it actually?
// (Example: if a URL preview was generated or updated, the message text won't have changed.)
// Only way to detect this is by text content. So we'll remove text events from eventsToReplace that have the same new text as text currently in the event.
for (let i = eventsToReplace.length; i--;) { // move backwards through array
const event = eventsToReplace[i]
if (!eventIsText(event)) continue // not text, can't analyse
const oldEvent = await api.getEvent(roomID, eventsToReplace[i].old.event_id)
const oldEventBodyWithoutQuotedReply = oldEvent.content.body?.replace(/^(>.*\n)*\n*/sm, "")
if (oldEventBodyWithoutQuotedReply !== event.newInnerContent.body) continue // event changed, must replace it
// Move it from eventsToRedact to unchangedEvents.
unchangedEvents.push(...eventsToReplace.filter(ev => ev.old.event_id === event.old.event_id))
eventsToReplace = eventsToReplace.filter(ev => ev.old.event_id !== event.old.event_id)
}
// We want to maintain exactly one part = 0 and one reaction_part = 0 database row at all times.
// This would be disrupted if existing events that are (reaction_)part = 0 will be redacted.
// If that is the case, pick a different existing or newly sent event to be (reaction_)part = 0.
@ -193,4 +211,3 @@ function makeReplacementEventContent(oldID, newFallbackContent, newInnerContent)
}
module.exports.editToChanges = editToChanges
module.exports.makeReplacementEventContent = makeReplacementEventContent

View file

@ -4,7 +4,14 @@ const data = require("../../../test/data")
const Ty = require("../../types")
test("edit2changes: edit by webhook", async t => {
const {senderMxid, eventsToRedact, eventsToReplace, eventsToSend, promotions} = await editToChanges(data.message_update.edit_by_webhook, data.guild.general, {})
let called = 0
const {senderMxid, eventsToRedact, eventsToReplace, eventsToSend, promotions} = await editToChanges(data.message_update.edit_by_webhook, data.guild.general, {
getEvent(roomID, eventID) {
called++
t.equal(eventID, "$zXSlyI78DQqQwwfPUSzZ1b-nXzbUrCDljJgnGDdoI10")
return {content: {body: "dummy"}}
}
})
t.deepEqual(eventsToRedact, [])
t.deepEqual(eventsToSend, [])
t.deepEqual(eventsToReplace, [{
@ -28,10 +35,15 @@ test("edit2changes: edit by webhook", async t => {
}])
t.equal(senderMxid, null)
t.deepEqual(promotions, [])
t.equal(called, 1)
})
test("edit2changes: bot response", async t => {
const {senderMxid, eventsToRedact, eventsToReplace, eventsToSend, promotions} = await editToChanges(data.message_update.bot_response, data.guild.general, {
getEvent(roomID, eventID) {
t.equal(eventID, "$fdD9OZ55xg3EAsfvLZza5tMhtjUO91Wg3Otuo96TplY")
return {content: {body: "dummy"}}
},
async getJoinedMembers(roomID) {
t.equal(roomID, "!hYnGGlPHlbujVVfktC:cadence.moe")
return new Promise(resolve => {
@ -123,7 +135,14 @@ test("edit2changes: add caption back to that image (due to it having a reaction,
})
test("edit2changes: stickers and attachments are not changed, only the content can be edited", async t => {
const {eventsToRedact, eventsToReplace, eventsToSend} = await editToChanges(data.message_update.edited_content_with_sticker_and_attachments, data.guild.general, {})
let called = 0
const {eventsToRedact, eventsToReplace, eventsToSend} = await editToChanges(data.message_update.edited_content_with_sticker_and_attachments, data.guild.general, {
getEvent(roomID, eventID) {
called++
t.equal(eventID, "$lnAF9IosAECTnlv9p2e18FG8rHn-JgYKHEHIh5qdFv4")
return {content: {body: "dummy"}}
}
})
t.deepEqual(eventsToRedact, [])
t.deepEqual(eventsToSend, [])
t.deepEqual(eventsToReplace, [{
@ -145,10 +164,16 @@ test("edit2changes: stickers and attachments are not changed, only the content c
}
}
}])
t.equal(called, 1)
})
test("edit2changes: edit of reply to skull webp attachment with content", async t => {
const {eventsToRedact, eventsToReplace, eventsToSend} = await editToChanges(data.message_update.edit_of_reply_to_skull_webp_attachment_with_content, data.guild.general, {})
const {eventsToRedact, eventsToReplace, eventsToSend} = await editToChanges(data.message_update.edit_of_reply_to_skull_webp_attachment_with_content, data.guild.general, {
getEvent(roomID, eventID) {
t.equal(eventID, "$vgTKOR5ZTYNMKaS7XvgEIDaOWZtVCEyzLLi5Pc5Gz4M")
return {content: {body: "dummy"}}
}
})
t.deepEqual(eventsToRedact, [])
t.deepEqual(eventsToSend, [])
t.deepEqual(eventsToReplace, [{
@ -177,7 +202,12 @@ test("edit2changes: edit of reply to skull webp attachment with content", async
})
test("edit2changes: edits the text event when multiple rows have part = 0 (should never happen in real life, but make sure the safety net works)", async t => {
const {eventsToRedact, eventsToReplace, eventsToSend} = await editToChanges(data.message_update.edited_content_with_sticker_and_attachments_but_all_parts_equal_0, data.guild.general, {})
const {eventsToRedact, eventsToReplace, eventsToSend} = await editToChanges(data.message_update.edited_content_with_sticker_and_attachments_but_all_parts_equal_0, data.guild.general, {
getEvent(roomID, eventID) {
t.equal(eventID, "$lnAF9IosAECTnlv9p2e18FG8rHn-JgYKHEHIh5qd999")
return {content: {body: "dummy"}}
}
})
t.deepEqual(eventsToRedact, [])
t.deepEqual(eventsToSend, [])
t.deepEqual(eventsToReplace, [{
@ -202,7 +232,12 @@ test("edit2changes: edits the text event when multiple rows have part = 0 (shoul
})
test("edit2changes: promotes the text event when multiple rows have part = 1 (should never happen in real life, but make sure the safety net works)", async t => {
const {eventsToRedact, eventsToReplace, eventsToSend, promotions} = await editToChanges(data.message_update.edited_content_with_sticker_and_attachments_but_all_parts_equal_1, data.guild.general, {})
const {eventsToRedact, eventsToReplace, eventsToSend, promotions} = await editToChanges(data.message_update.edited_content_with_sticker_and_attachments_but_all_parts_equal_1, data.guild.general, {
getEvent(roomID, eventID) {
t.equal(eventID, "$lnAF9IosAECTnlv9p2e18FG8rHn-JgYKHEHIh5qd111")
return {content: {body: "dummy"}}
}
})
t.deepEqual(eventsToRedact, [])
t.deepEqual(eventsToSend, [])
t.deepEqual(eventsToReplace, [{
@ -279,32 +314,31 @@ test("edit2changes: generated embed", async t => {
})
test("edit2changes: generated embed on a reply", async t => {
const {senderMxid, eventsToRedact, eventsToReplace, eventsToSend, promotions} = await editToChanges(data.message_update.embed_generated_on_reply, data.guild.general, {})
let called = 0
const {senderMxid, eventsToRedact, eventsToReplace, eventsToSend, promotions} = await editToChanges(data.message_update.embed_generated_on_reply, data.guild.general, {
getEvent(roomID, eventID) {
called++
t.equal(eventID, "$UTqiL3Zj3FC4qldxRLggN1fhygpKl8sZ7XGY5f9MNbF")
return {
type: "m.room.message",
content: {
// Unfortunately the edited message doesn't include the message_reference field. Fine. Whatever. It looks normal if you're using a good client.
body: "> a Discord user: [Replied-to message content wasn't provided by Discord]"
+ "\n\nhttps://matrix.to/#/!BnKuBPCvyfOkhcUjEu:cadence.moe/$aLVZyiC3HlOu-prCSIaXlQl68I8leUdnPFiCwkgn6qM",
format: "org.matrix.custom.html",
formatted_body: "<mx-reply><blockquote><a href=\"https://matrix.to/#/!BnKuBPCvyfOkhcUjEu:cadence.moe/$aLVZyiC3HlOu-prCSIaXlQl68I8leUdnPFiCwkgn6qM\">In reply to</a> a Discord user<br>[Replied-to message content wasn't provided by Discord]</blockquote></mx-reply><a href=\"https://matrix.to/#/!BnKuBPCvyfOkhcUjEu:cadence.moe/$aLVZyiC3HlOu-prCSIaXlQl68I8leUdnPFiCwkgn6qM\">https://matrix.to/#/!BnKuBPCvyfOkhcUjEu:cadence.moe/$aLVZyiC3HlOu-prCSIaXlQl68I8leUdnPFiCwkgn6qM</a>",
"m.mentions": {},
"m.relates_to": {
event_id: "$UTqiL3Zj3FC4qldxRLggN1fhygpKl8sZ7XGY5f9MNbF",
rel_type: "m.replace",
},
msgtype: "m.text",
}
}
}
})
t.deepEqual(eventsToRedact, [])
t.deepEqual(eventsToReplace, [{
oldID: "$UTqiL3Zj3FC4qldxRLggN1fhygpKl8sZ7XGY5f9MNbF",
newContent: {
$type: "m.room.message",
// Unfortunately the edited message doesn't include the message_reference field. Fine. Whatever. It looks normal if you're using a good client.
body: "> a Discord user: [Replied-to message content wasn't provided by Discord]"
+ "\n\n* https://matrix.to/#/!BnKuBPCvyfOkhcUjEu:cadence.moe/$aLVZyiC3HlOu-prCSIaXlQl68I8leUdnPFiCwkgn6qM",
format: "org.matrix.custom.html",
formatted_body: "<mx-reply><blockquote><a href=\"https://matrix.to/#/!BnKuBPCvyfOkhcUjEu:cadence.moe/$aLVZyiC3HlOu-prCSIaXlQl68I8leUdnPFiCwkgn6qM\">In reply to</a> a Discord user<br>[Replied-to message content wasn't provided by Discord]</blockquote></mx-reply>* <a href=\"https://matrix.to/#/!BnKuBPCvyfOkhcUjEu:cadence.moe/$aLVZyiC3HlOu-prCSIaXlQl68I8leUdnPFiCwkgn6qM\">https://matrix.to/#/!BnKuBPCvyfOkhcUjEu:cadence.moe/$aLVZyiC3HlOu-prCSIaXlQl68I8leUdnPFiCwkgn6qM</a>",
"m.mentions": {},
"m.new_content": {
body: "https://matrix.to/#/!BnKuBPCvyfOkhcUjEu:cadence.moe/$aLVZyiC3HlOu-prCSIaXlQl68I8leUdnPFiCwkgn6qM",
format: "org.matrix.custom.html",
formatted_body: "<a href=\"https://matrix.to/#/!BnKuBPCvyfOkhcUjEu:cadence.moe/$aLVZyiC3HlOu-prCSIaXlQl68I8leUdnPFiCwkgn6qM\">https://matrix.to/#/!BnKuBPCvyfOkhcUjEu:cadence.moe/$aLVZyiC3HlOu-prCSIaXlQl68I8leUdnPFiCwkgn6qM</a>",
"m.mentions": {},
msgtype: "m.text",
},
"m.relates_to": {
event_id: "$UTqiL3Zj3FC4qldxRLggN1fhygpKl8sZ7XGY5f9MNbF",
rel_type: "m.replace",
},
msgtype: "m.text",
},
}])
t.deepEqual(eventsToReplace, [])
t.deepEqual(eventsToSend, [{
$type: "m.room.message",
msgtype: "m.notice",
@ -324,4 +358,5 @@ test("edit2changes: generated embed on a reply", async t => {
"nextEvent": true,
}])
t.equal(senderMxid, "@_ooye_cadence:cadence.moe")
t.equal(called, 1)
})