|
|
596b8f14bb
|
docs: add brutal professional assessment of Makepad map codebase
Comprehensive assessment comparing Makepad maps (14,182 lines) vs
Slint native maps (376 lines).
Key findings:
- Makepad is 37x more complex than Slint for similar functionality
- Architecture: Over-engineered with god objects (3/10)
- Performance: Good optimizations, poor measurability (6/10)
- Bugs: Many fixed, likely many remain (5/10)
- Design: Inconsistent, poorly documented (4/10)
- Security: Good hardening, incomplete threat model (7/10)
- Code Quality: Massive duplication, poor organization (3/10)
Overall Score: 4.2/10 (Failing)
Includes 18-week execution plan to fix the codebase:
- Phase 0: Assessment & Planning (1 week)
- Phase 1: Critical Bug Fixes (2 weeks)
- Phase 2: Architecture Refactoring (4 weeks)
- Phase 3: Performance Optimization (3 weeks)
- Phase 4: Code Quality (3 weeks)
- Phase 5: Testing & Validation (2 weeks)
- Phase 6: Security Hardening (2 weeks)
- Phase 7: Documentation & Polish (1 week)
Total: 18 weeks to production-ready codebase.
Recommendation: Execute the plan or consider rewriting using
Slint's approach (10x simpler).
|
2026-07-27 17:43:13 +00:00 |
|
