diff --git a/m2d/converters/event-to-message.js b/m2d/converters/event-to-message.js
index 2984e8e1..6b762b41 100644
--- a/m2d/converters/event-to-message.js
+++ b/m2d/converters/event-to-message.js
@@ -206,11 +206,10 @@ function getCodeContent(preCode) {
  */
 function convertEmoji(mxcUrl, nameForGuess, allowSpriteSheetIndicator, allowLink) {
 	// Get the known emoji from the database.
-	let row
-	if (mxcUrl) row = select("emoji", ["emoji_id", "name", "animated"], {mxc_url: mxcUrl}).get()
+	if (mxcUrl) var row = select("emoji", ["emoji_id", "name", "animated"], {mxc_url: mxcUrl}).get()
 	// Now we have to search all servers to see if we're able to send this emoji.
 	if (row) {
-		const found = [...discord.guilds.values()].find(g => g.emojis.find(e => e.id === row.id))
+		const found = [...discord.guilds.values()].find(g => g.emojis.find(e => e.id === row?.emoji_id))
 		if (!found) row = null
 	}
 	// Or, if we don't have an emoji right now, we search for the name instead.
@@ -220,7 +219,7 @@ function convertEmoji(mxcUrl, nameForGuess, allowSpriteSheetIndicator, allowLink
 			/** @type {{name: string, id: string, animated: number}[]} */
 			// @ts-ignore
 			const emojis = guild.emojis
-			const found = emojis.find(e => e.id === row?.id || e.name?.toLowerCase() === nameForGuessLower)
+			const found = emojis.find(e => e.name?.toLowerCase() === nameForGuessLower)
 			if (found) {
 				row = {
 					animated: found.animated,
diff --git a/m2d/converters/event-to-message.test.js b/m2d/converters/event-to-message.test.js
index b404e59f..a802d288 100644
--- a/m2d/converters/event-to-message.test.js
+++ b/m2d/converters/event-to-message.test.js
@@ -3794,6 +3794,36 @@ test("event2message: static emojis work", async t => {
 	)
 })
 
+test("event2message: emojis in other servers are reused if they have the same title text", async t => {
+	t.deepEqual(
+		await eventToMessage({
+			type: "m.room.message",
+			sender: "@cadence:cadence.moe",
+			content: {
+				msgtype: "m.text",
+				body: ":hippo:",
+				format: "org.matrix.custom.html",
+				formatted_body: '<img data-mx-emoticon height=\"32\" src=\"mxc://cadence.moe/123456\" title=\":hippo:\" alt=\":hippo:\">'
+			},
+			event_id: "$g07oYSZFWBkxohNEfywldwgcWj1hbhDzQ1sBAKvqOOU",
+			room_id: "!CzvdIdUQXgUjDVKxeU:cadence.moe"
+		}),
+		{
+			ensureJoined: [],
+			messagesToDelete: [],
+			messagesToEdit: [],
+			messagesToSend: [{
+				username: "cadence [they]",
+				content: "<:hippo:230201364309868544>",
+				avatar_url: "https://matrix.cadence.moe/_matrix/media/r0/download/cadence.moe/azCAhThKTojXSZJRoWwZmhvU",
+				allowed_mentions: {
+					parse: ["users", "roles"]
+				}
+			}]
+		}
+	)
+})
+
 test("event2message: animated emojis work", async t => {
 	t.deepEqual(
 		await eventToMessage({